Spotify is no longer just a streaming app, it's a social network

Spotify screen shown an 2 smartphones

Image Credits: Spotify

With Spotify’s recent launch of comments on podcasts, the streamer is taking yet another step toward building a social networking experience in an app primarily known for music. With comments, podcasters can now engage with their listeners directly within Spotify, as they can with other interactive features like Polls and Q&As. Combined with the app’s 2023 revamp, which added a TikTok-like discovery feed, artist profiles where creators can hawk merchandise and concert tickets, as well as the ability to post to stories, Spotify’s app is shaping up to be a social network centered around all things audio, not just a music-streaming app.

Following this week’s added support for comments on podcast episode pages — a social networking feature if there ever was one — the question now is whether Spotify will add something similar for music artists in the future. This could be an even more compelling addition to the app, as the fanbases around musicians tend to be larger and more active than those around most podcasts.

When speaking with Spotify VP of Podcast Product Maya Prohovnik about the launch of comments, we ventured a question about adding support for comments on artists’ pages, too.

Prohovnik didn’t outright deny that such an idea was under consideration, instead initially declining to comment, before adding that: “I can see a world where we extend [support for comments] to other formats on Spotify, but we always want to do whatever is right for the format, and those types of creators and artists.”

It’s worth noting that the idea to build a social network in a music app has been tried before by Spotify’s top competitor, Apple.

In 2010, Steve Jobs introduced iTunes’ new social network Ping as “Facebook and Twitter meet iTunes,” calling it a “social network all about music.” Clearly, Jobs was onto something, but Ping never found success in the Apple founder’s lifetime. Shortly after Jobs’ death, Apple shut down Ping in 2012, a rare flop for the iPhone maker. Apple later tried again with a social feature for musicians, Connect, which also didn’t last.

Even today, Apple continues to half-heartedly embrace social networking in its Apple Music streaming service, with an optional feature that will periodically check the contacts on your devices to recommend new friends to follow so you can see what they’re listening to.

Image Credits: Spotify

However, unlike Apple, Spotify has never made a bold declaration that it was building a social network focused on audio.

Rather, the company has quietly and slowly rolled out a series of features that simply make the app more social for both creators and their fans. With last year’s redesign, for instance, Spotify added in-app video feeds across its Home pages, including its tabs for Music, Podcasts and now Audiobooks. Though those feeds’ designs have been tweaked since launch, the move served as a signal that Spotify was taking learnings from Gen Z’s preferred social network, TikTok, when designing its own product.

Spotify CEO Daniel Ek spoke to TikTok’s influence during the company’s Q1 2024 earnings, telling investors that TikTok and others had “improved the user experience” and that the industry was “learning about these trends and trying to improve our products.”

“… We are not any different than anyone else in that we’re trying to learn from the marketplace,” Ek said, hinting at the app’s TikTok inspiration. “We learn what consumers like. We try to improve upon it and make the best possible user experience.”

Image Credits: Spotify

Over the past year, the company also added new ways for artists to reach fans, through a Spotify Clips feature, that worked similarly to Stories on other social networks. Here, artists could add 30-second videos to their profile pages and album pages.

Artists can also get fans excited about new releases with Countdown Pages, and fans continue to hear from favorite artists through video messages via the company’s annual Spotify Wrapped campaign. Meanwhile, Spotify users can continue to follow creators and friends on the platform to stay updated on the latest music and events and see what friends are streaming. They can collaborate on playlists with others in many ways, including in real time. The company has previously been spotted testing a Community feature that would allow users to see, in real time, what others were streaming.

With the addition of comments, Spotify envisions an app where users aren’t just launching audio and then returning their phone to their pocket, but one where they’re actively engaged, sharing their thoughts, feelings and opinions as they would on a traditional social network.

Combined, these features are beginning to add up to an app that’s not just another music streamer, but one that aims to compete for users’ time — and eventually, the ad dollars — spent on larger social networks.

Chasing YouTube, Spotify adds comments to podcasts

Spotify is no longer just a streaming app, it's a social network

Spotify screen shown an 2 smartphones

Image Credits: Spotify

With Spotify’s recent launch of comments on podcasts, the streamer is taking yet another step toward building a social networking experience in an app primarily known for music. With comments, podcasters can now engage with their listeners directly within Spotify, as they can with other interactive features like Polls and Q&As. Combined with the app’s 2023 revamp, which added a TikTok-like discovery feed, artist profiles where creators can hawk merchandise and concert tickets, as well as the ability to post to stories, Spotify’s app is shaping up to be a social network centered around all things audio, not just a music-streaming app.

Following this week’s added support for comments on podcast episode pages — a social networking feature if there ever was one — the question now is whether Spotify will add something similar for music artists in the future. This could be an even more compelling addition to the app, as the fanbases around musicians tend to be larger and more active than those around most podcasts.

When speaking with Spotify VP of Podcast Product Maya Prohovnik about the launch of comments, we ventured a question about adding support for comments on artists’ pages, too.

Prohovnik didn’t outright deny that such an idea was under consideration, instead initially declining to comment, before adding that: “I can see a world where we extend [support for comments] to other formats on Spotify, but we always want to do whatever is right for the format, and those types of creators and artists.”

It’s worth noting that the idea to build a social network in a music app has been tried before by Spotify’s top competitor, Apple.

In 2010, Steve Jobs introduced iTunes’ new social network Ping as “Facebook and Twitter meet iTunes,” calling it a “social network all about music.” Clearly, Jobs was onto something, but Ping never found success in the Apple founder’s lifetime. Shortly after Jobs’ death, Apple shut down Ping in 2012, a rare flop for the iPhone maker. Apple later tried again with a social feature for musicians, Connect, which also didn’t last.

Even today, Apple continues to half-heartedly embrace social networking in its Apple Music streaming service, with an optional feature that will periodically check the contacts on your devices to recommend new friends to follow so you can see what they’re listening to.

Image Credits: Spotify

However, unlike Apple, Spotify has never made a bold declaration that it was building a social network focused on audio.

Rather, the company has quietly and slowly rolled out a series of features that simply make the app more social for both creators and their fans. With last year’s redesign, for instance, Spotify added in-app video feeds across its Home pages, including its tabs for Music, Podcasts and now Audiobooks. Though those feeds’ designs have been tweaked since launch, the move served as a signal that Spotify was taking learnings from Gen Z’s preferred social network, TikTok, when designing its own product.

Spotify CEO Daniel Ek spoke to TikTok’s influence during the company’s Q1 2024 earnings, telling investors that TikTok and others had “improved the user experience” and that the industry was “learning about these trends and trying to improve our products.”

“… We are not any different than anyone else in that we’re trying to learn from the marketplace,” Ek said, hinting at the app’s TikTok inspiration. “We learn what consumers like. We try to improve upon it and make the best possible user experience.”

Image Credits: Spotify

Over the past year, the company also added new ways for artists to reach fans, through a Spotify Clips feature, that worked similarly to Stories on other social networks. Here, artists could add 30-second videos to their profile pages and album pages.

Artists can also get fans excited about new releases with Countdown Pages, and fans continue to hear from favorite artists through video messages via the company’s annual Spotify Wrapped campaign. Meanwhile, Spotify users can continue to follow creators and friends on the platform to stay updated on the latest music and events and see what friends are streaming. They can collaborate on playlists with others in many ways, including in real time. The company has previously been spotted testing a Community feature that would allow users to see, in real time, what others were streaming.

With the addition of comments, Spotify envisions an app where users aren’t just launching audio and then returning their phone to their pocket, but one where they’re actively engaged, sharing their thoughts, feelings and opinions as they would on a traditional social network.

Combined, these features are beginning to add up to an app that’s not just another music streamer, but one that aims to compete for users’ time — and eventually, the ad dollars — spent on larger social networks.

Chasing YouTube, Spotify adds comments to podcasts

You can no longer use Tumblr’s tipping feature 

Photo illustration of a Tumblr logo displayed on a smartphone with a COVID 19 sample image in the background.

Image Credits: Omar Marques/SOPA Images/LightRocket / Getty Images

Tumblr officially shut down “Tips,” an opt-in feature where creators could receive one-time payments from their followers. 

As of today, the tipping icon has automatically disappeared from all posts and blogs with the feature enabled. Creators that use the feature should note that June 15 is the last day they can withdraw money they received from tipping. 

The reason for shutting down the feature is simple: it failed to gain traction. According to a post written by the company last month, “Tipping hasn’t seen the usage we’d hoped for.” Additionally, it has been Tumblr’s plan since last year’s reorg to put an end to things that aren’t performing well.

“While this will affect a very small number of you, we know that those of you who do Tip do so with great admiration for your Tumblr peers, and we’re sorry to be taking this away from you,” the company added.

In 2022, Tumblr introduced Tips as a complementary feature to Post+, its subscription offering that allowed creators to put content behind a paywall. However, Post+ was discontinued last year due to user backlash. It seems that users were tired of their favorite platform trying to make money from them, so it’s not surprising that the platform’s attempt to use Tips didn’t work out.

In terms of other monetization features, Tumblr still has its Supporter badge, which costs $2.99/month or $29.99/year and can be displayed on their blog like any other badge. The company explained on its website that the supporter badge will appear “shiner and shiner” as time goes on and the user continues to support the platform.

Tumblr expands its tip jar feature to enable blog-level tipping

Instagram and Threads will no longer 'proactively' recommend political content

The Threads logo on a smartphone

Image Credits: Bloomberg / Gabby Jones (opens in a new window) / Getty Images

Meta doesn’t want its new app Threads to become another Twitter, full of heated political debates and the resulting toxicity that entails. In an announcement today, the company detailed how it will approach the recommendation of political content across both Instagram and its sister app, Threads, a competitor to Elon Musk’s X. In short, it will no longer push politics on users. Similar to Meta’s existing policies on Facebook, Instagram and Threads’ recommendation engines now won’t proactively suggest political posts to users by default, the company said on Friday.

On Facebook, Meta has reduced the amount of political content that appears in the Feed (formerly News Feed), Reels, Facebook Watch (videos), Groups You Should Join and Pages You May Like recommendations. Now, it’s announcing this same approach will come to Instagram and Reels in the months leading up to the U.S. 2024 elections.

In an announcement shared on the Instagram blog and Meta Transparency Center, the company said the changes to Instagram’s app will impact areas like Instagram Reels and Instagram Explore, as well as the In-Feed Recommendations across both Instagram and Threads. With the latter move, Meta is differentiating its new app from Twitter, now called X, in a significant way.

Twitter has often been home to political debate, an extension of its function as a real-time news network. But Instagram has been distancing Threads from news, having delayed the addition of a “trends” feature, as X offers. Instagram head Adam Mosseri also specifically stated in October that Threads won’t “amplify news” on its platform.

To be clear, Meta’s coming changes impact Instagram’s role in recommending content, but not how it shows content from accounts users already follow, the company said. For example, if an account that’s not eligible for recommendation posts political content, like news about elections, laws or other social topics, that account’s content will still reach its followers via the Feed and Stories. It just won’t be proactively recommended to non-followers.

Image Credits: Meta

Instagram says professional accounts will be able to use an Account Status feature to check their current eligibility status and can choose to edit or remove posts from this page. They can also request a review if they disagree with Instagram’s decision on a piece of content, or can choose to stop posting content to be eligible for recommendation again. (The company didn’t say how long it would need to refrain from political posts to once again be eligible, however.)

In addition, users who do want political content recommended will be able to turn this on in their Settings on both Instagram and Threads. Facebook will also get a similar control at some point in the future.

Removing politics from recommendation surfaces and forcing users to toggle it back on if they want to see it are changes that come after years of Meta shouldering the blame for much of the world’s political unrest. Whether that’s being held responsible for genocide in Myanmar or for the January 6 attack on the Capitol here in the U.S., Meta’s social networking apps have been used to amplify hate and misinformation, leading to violence. Clearly, the company wants to put more distance between what it pushes to its users via algorithms and the sort of content that could become problematic at scale.

The move could also help to soothe lawmakers who are weighing how to regulate Big Tech companies that have achieved monopoly power.

Meta says the changes will roll out to Instagram and Threads users “slowly over time to get this right,” without offering a specific date they would be fully available to all.

YouTube no longer experiencing outages, site confirms

YouTube icon

Image Credits: TechCrunch

Update: The outages have been resolved as of around 3:00 p.m. ET.

A Google spokesperson told TechCrunch that there was a surge in traffic beginning at around 10:25 a.m. ET, which correlated with an unrelated service disruption. Though the spokesperson didn’t specify further details, that timing lines up with a major outage at Meta, where users were unable to access Instagram, Facebook and Threads. The spokesperson said that a small number of users were impacted, and there is no evidence of cyberattacks.

Several social media websites are experiencing outages on Tuesday morning. YouTube confirmed that some users are having trouble loading videos on the platform; meanwhile, platforms like Discord and Meta’s Threads, Facebook and Instagram are down as well.

According to a post on Google’s support page, users may be experiencing an empty home page, error messages, spinning wheels while scrolling on Shorts and running out of videos to watch on Shorts’ infinite feed.

“Rest assured we’re working on a fix now!” the post says.

YouTube also shared an update on its X account, which links to the support page.

The root cause of these widespread outages remains unclear. Sometimes, several platforms go down at the same time if they’re using the same cloud computing services, like AWS. But AWS is not reporting any issues; plus, companies like Meta and Google are large enough to operate data centers independently of providers like AWS, making outages of this nature uncommon.

Discord comes back online after widespread outage

Facebook, Instagram and Threads were all down in massive Meta outage on Super Tuesday